Starting Today, PTAB Judges Are Back to Weighing Patent Challenges. A Close Call Goes to the Patent Owner.

Attorney advertising. This article is general information, not legal advice.

If you own a U.S. patent, an inter partes review can put that patent back in front of the Patent Trial and Appeal Board. If you want to challenge a competitor’s patent, you have to clear the institution gate first. Starting today, that gate works a little differently on the merits.

On November 10, 2026, USPTO Director John A. Squires and General Counsel and Supervisory Solicitor John F. Duffy issued a memorandum returning merits-based institution decisions in inter partes review (IPR) and post-grant review (PGR) to PTAB judges. The change takes effect November 16, 2026.

What changed, and what didn’t

The Director will still screen petitions first on discretionary and other non-merits grounds. Petitions that survive that screen go to a three-judge PTAB panel, which decides institution on the merits on the Director’s behalf. If that panel institutes a trial, a different panel—with none of the institution judges—will hear the case.

The updated process applies to IPR and PGR petitions that do not yet have a notice referring the case for a merits review. The memorandum also makes clear that this delegation does not take away the Director’s statutory authority to grant or deny institution.

A closer look at the merits

The statutory floors have not changed. For an IPR, the petitioner still has to show a “reasonable likelihood” of prevailing on at least one challenged claim. For a PGR, the showing is “more likely than not.” The memorandum adds guidance on how the Board should look at the petition as a whole.

If the petitioner fails to make the required showing for a “substantial majority” of the challenged claims, the PTAB will deny institution. The same result follows if the patent owner’s preliminary response, or the Board itself, raises a reasonable argument, well supported by reliable, credible evidence, that the petition falls short on a substantial majority of the claims.

The memorandum is also clear about a tie on a particular claim. If the arguments for and against unpatentability are both reasonably supported—that is, the evidence and arguments are in “equipoise”—the Board will not treat the petitioner as having met the IPR or PGR standard on that claim. Patently-O summed up the point as “tie goes to denial.” The Office describes these guidelines as illustrative, not exhaustive.

Petitioners also need to explain, element by element, where each claim limitation is found in the prior art. Merely pointing to an examiner’s earlier findings is not enough.

Takeaways for Iowa patent owners and founders

  • A close or uneven petition is more likely to be denied. Small patent owners facing an IPR may get a somewhat higher bar in their favor on the merits. That is guidance, not a promise of any particular result.
  • The Director still screens first. Discretionary and other non-merits issues remain in the Director’s hands.
  • Institution and trial will be split. The judges who decide whether to institute will not be the judges who try the case.
  • Challengers should expect closer merits review. Founders who want to challenge a competitor’s patent should plan for a tighter, more complete petition.
  • Build the full record early. Institution now looks at the petition as a whole, not just whether one claim clears the statutory floor.

For a recent example of how an IPR can turn on the full record—including evidence of copying and industry praise—see our Google v. DDC Technology post. Our patents page covers drafting, searching, and the application process.

Sources: the USPTO news release, the November 10, 2026 memorandum, and Patently-O’s November 10 summary.

Talk with an Iowa patent attorney

Jason Sytsma helps Iowa manufacturers, startups, and inventors decide what to protect and how to respond when a patent is challenged. Learn more on the About Jason page and the firm bio.

Contact the office to request a consultation. Any engagement is subject to conflicts review, an engagement agreement, and applicable professional-responsibility rules. This article is attorney advertising and is intended for general educational purposes only; it is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Results vary, and past experience does not guarantee a particular outcome.

About the author

Jason R. Sytsma, registered patent attorney, Shuttleworth & Ingersoll

About Jason · Firm bio at Shuttleworth & Ingersoll