Attorney advertising. This article is general information, not legal advice.
A hand-held VR viewer that holds a smartphone can look like a simple piece of hardware. Put a phone in a box, add lenses, and give the user a way to tap the screen from outside. That kind of invention can still survive an obviousness challenge when the patent owner can show that others copied it and that people in the industry praised what it did.
On November 5, 2026, in Google LLC v. DDC Technology, LLC, Nos. 2025-1315, -1316, and -1330, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit affirmed three Patent Trial and Appeal Board final written decisions. Circuit Judge Reyna wrote the opinion, joined by Circuit Judges Hughes and Stark. The decision is precedential.
The patents and the IPRs
The patents, U.S. Patent Nos. 9,420,075, 10,528,199, and 11,093,001, share a specification describing a VR viewer for a conventional smartphone. The housing holds the phone so the touchscreen faces the user. An input mechanism accessible from outside the housing moves inside and contacts the touchscreen when actuated, creating a detectable touch event.
Google petitioned for inter partes review in IPR2023-00707, -00709, and -00711, relying on a combination of Kondo (a Japanese publication describing a smartphone attachment with a remote-touch circuit) and Chu (a U.S. publication describing a button-actuated probe that contacts a capacitive touchscreen through a waterproof housing). The Board found that Google proved some claims unpatentable but failed to prove obviousness for the surviving claims: claims 1–12, 14, and 18–20 of the ’075 patent; claims 1, 2, 4–6, and 17–26 of the ’199 patent; and claims 27 and 28 of the ’001 patent.
Copying and industry praise carried the day on claim 1
For claim 1 of the ’075 and ’199 patents, the Board found that Kondo and Chu taught every limitation and that a skilled artisan would have been motivated to combine them with a reasonable expectation of success. That was not the end of the analysis. The Board weighed DDC’s objective indicia of nonobviousness and concluded that those facts outweighed Google’s obviousness evidence.
The Board found strong evidence that Google’s GCV2 viewer copied DDC’s DODOcase VR 1.2 viewer and a prototype developed by inventor Patrick Buckley. It compared the products to each other, not merely to the claims, and treated differences in the input mechanisms as minor, non-material modifications. The Federal Circuit affirmed that copying finding.
The Board also gave moderate weight to industry praise in the form of emails from three Google engineers responding to videos of Buckley’s prototype (“That button is genius,” “That’s an ingenious button!”). The Board discounted the business context of those compliments but still treated two of them as praise tied to the claimed input mechanism. The Federal Circuit held that finding was supported by substantial evidence.
Google argued that its “strong” obviousness case should have outweighed the secondary considerations. The court noted that the Board never described Google’s evidence as strong. Putting the Board’s factual findings on the table—including strong copying and moderate praise—the Federal Circuit saw no legal error in the Board’s balancing. “We cannot say as a matter of law that Google’s evidence of obviousness is strong enough to outweigh DDC’s evidence of nonobviousness.”
Objective indicia aren’t optional, and IPRs aren’t patent examination
The opinion walks through Graham v. John Deere and decades of Federal Circuit precedent: when objective indicia are present, they must be considered in every case on the way to an obviousness determination. Secondary considerations can be among the most probative evidence in the record, and they are not automatically overruled by a strong prima facie case.
The court also rejected any notion of formal burden-shifting under Graham in an IPR. Burden-shifting tools that make sense during examination—where the examiner often has no objective-indicia evidence—do not apply in the adjudicatory context of an IPR. All of the Graham factors go on the table together.
Other claim disputes also failed
Google also lost on claim construction and related obviousness theories for other surviving claims. The court affirmed the Board’s reading of “disposed on” in claim 18 of the ’075 patent (excluding connections that are “far removed”), the construction of “lever” in claim 20 as “a stiff body pivoted on a fulcrum,” and the Board’s determinations on claims 27 and 28 of the ’001 patent, including that Google had forfeited a late claim-construction theory on claim 28.
Takeaways for Iowa hardware founders and inventors
- Keep the paper trail. Emails, demos, prototypes, competitor teardown notes, and access evidence can matter years later when someone challenges your patent as obvious.
- Copying is about the product, not just the claims. Showing that a competitor replicated your device can weigh heavily for nonobviousness.
- Praise still counts, with context. Contemporaneous compliments from people who understand the technology can help, even if the Board discounts business politeness.
- A simple-looking invention isn’t automatically obvious. If the prior-art case is only middling, objective indicia can tip the balance.
- Don’t treat secondary considerations as an afterthought. In litigation and in IPR responses, develop them early and tie them to the claimed features.
For more on how prior-art and claim-scope fights play out at the Federal Circuit, see our Precision Planting v. Maschio post on patent drawings as prior art and our Satius enablement post. Our patents page covers drafting, searching, and the application process.
Sources: the Federal Circuit’s precedential opinion in Google v. DDC Technology and IPWatchdog’s summary.
Talk with an Iowa patent attorney
Jason Sytsma helps Iowa manufacturers, hardware startups, and inventors decide what to protect and how to draft and claim it. Learn more on the About Jason page and the firm bio.
Contact the office to request a consultation. Any engagement is subject to conflicts review, an engagement agreement, and applicable professional-responsibility rules. This article is attorney advertising and is intended for general educational purposes only; it is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Results vary, and past experience does not guarantee a particular outcome.
