Attorney advertising. This article is general information, not legal advice.
Iowa equipment and ag-hardware makers often assume that a distinctive look becomes a trademark after enough years on the market. A new Trademark Trial and Appeal Board decision shows why years of sales, by themselves, usually are not enough.
On November 13, 2026, in In re Groves Incorporated, Inc., Serial No. 98373316, the Board affirmed a refusal to register a diagonal wire-panel product design for storage carts, racks, lockers, shelves, cabinets, and work tables. Judge Lebow wrote the opinion. The decision is not precedential, so it doesn’t bind future panels.
A product’s look starts at a disadvantage
Product design cannot be inherently distinctive. Under Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Samara Bros., Inc., the applicant has to prove that the design has acquired distinctiveness—that buyers see it as a source identifier, not just as part of the product. That burden is heavier for a product configuration than for a word mark or packaging.
Groves sought to register a three-dimensional panel of intersecting wires: one set running horizontally, the other at an angle, forming a repeating pattern of parallelograms. It markets the goods under the word mark READY RACK, which was not at issue in the appeal. The application claimed first use anywhere as of February 28, 2006, and first use in commerce as of September 30, 2006—more than 20 years before the Board’s decision.
Why the evidence fell short
Groves submitted its president’s affidavit and nine affidavits from firefighters, including two distributors and an architect who is a volunteer firefighter. The Board accepted that some people in the fire-equipment trade can tell a diagonal or “diamond” pattern from a square-wire pattern and associate the diagonal look with a particular source. But the identified goods are not limited to firefighting. They include carts for domestic and commercial use, and storage furniture that is not restricted to a firehouse market. Evidence from that narrower group of buyers did not show how the average purchaser of the goods, as identified, perceives the design. There was no survey.
Length of use was not enough on its own. The Board also noted that Groves’ catalogs offered square-wire versions of goods in the same categories. “A design that Applicant itself does not use consistently across the identified goods is less likely to be perceived as indicating a single source for those goods than a design used consistently across the goods.”
Advertising did not close the gap. Groves claimed spending of $100,000 to $150,000 a year, several million dollars over the life of the company, and attendance at about a dozen fire-industry trade shows a year. The Board found that the ads and catalogs prominently featured the word mark READY RACK, and related logos, as the primary source identifier. Spending shows effort, the Board wrote, but not that the effort taught buyers to treat the panel as a mark. The materials did not “direct purchasers to the configuration as an indication of source.” What tends to help is “look-for” advertising that tells buyers to look for the design itself.
Growth in distributors, from about 173 in 2006 to more than 500, also carried little weight without sales figures, pricing, or market-share evidence. The Board found no probative evidence of intentional copying.
Taken together, the record showed long use and advertising of the goods, but not that the primary significance of the panel, to the relevant purchasers, is source rather than the product. The Board affirmed the refusal under Sections 1, 2, and 45 of the Trademark Act.
Takeaways for Iowa equipment and ag-hardware makers
- Years of sales don’t automatically make a look a trademark. Product design needs proof that buyers use the design to identify the source.
- Use the design consistently. Selling the same category of goods in a different pattern undercuts the claim that the look points to one source.
- “Look-for” advertising matters. Ads that push a word mark, without pointing buyers to the design, may not do the work.
- Match the evidence to the goods. Affidavits from one niche of buyers may not cover a broader identification of goods.
- A design patent is a different tool. It can protect ornamental appearance for a limited term without the acquired-distinctiveness showing a product-configuration trademark requires. It is not a substitute for a trademark, and it is not a guarantee of any result.
Our trademarks overview and guide to registering a trademark cover filing basics. For the design-patent option, see our patents page and our guide to utility versus design patents.
Sources: the TTAB opinion in In re Groves Incorporated, Inc., Serial No. 98373316 (mailed Nov. 13, 2026), the TTABVUE docket, and commentary on the TTABlog.
Talk with Iowa trademark counsel
Jason Sytsma helps Iowa manufacturers, equipment makers, and brand owners clear, register, and protect names, logos, and product appearance. Learn more on the About Jason page and the firm bio.
Contact the office to request a consultation. Any engagement is subject to conflicts review, an engagement agreement, and applicable professional-responsibility rules. This article is attorney advertising and is intended for general educational purposes only; it is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Results vary, and past experience does not guarantee a particular outcome.
